|
A number of other pieces of information are important to psychiatrists
as they formulate the case of someone's depression. These include:
- The number and nature of previous episodes of depression
- Family history of mental illness, including mood and anxiety disorders
- Family history of completed suicides
- The individual's growing up experiences (socio-developmental history)
- Current suicidal thoughts, plans, urges, etc.
- Number and nature of previous suicide attempts, if any
- Previous psychotropic medication trials, including anti-depressants
(and how long they were used, whether they worked or not, what side-effects
they produced, and why they were discontinued, etc.)
Recurrence and Prior Episodes of Depression
Psychiatrists will often inquire about the number and nature of previous episodes
of depression an individual has suffered from because epidemiological data suggest
that an individual who has had 3 or more major depressive episodes prior to the age
of 35 is very likely to have a highly recurrent, chronic form of the illness. With
each episode, apparently, the risk for a subsequent episode is increased.
Genes and Environment in the Development of Depression
Because people are thought to be the product of their genetics and environment
(including experiences), it is important to understand how each may be contributing
to the expression of a mood disorder. Family trees of individuals with recurrent
major depressive disorder, for example, will often reveal other individuals with
significant mood and anxiety disorders. The current understanding of the genetics
of depression is that certain genes (many of which are not yet identified) confer
to an individual vulnerability to episodes of depression.[*]
At the same time, there is evidence that certain experiences can also predict
whether someone will suffer from a significant depressive disorder in his life.
These experiences include a history of child maltreatment, including emotional abuse,
physical abuse, sexual abuse and profound neglect.[*] There is also evidence that
mothers who suffer from untreated depression increase the risk that their children
will suffer from depression - above and beyond the genetic risk that is transmitted
to them.
Hence, it seems reasonable to speculate that with depression, as with most other
medical conditions, genes and environment interact in the development of the illness.
Family History of Depression
I find that inquiring about family history of mental illness, including depressive
disorders, often helps patients understand that genetics may play a key role in the
manifestation of their illness. Furthermore, a family history of completed suicide
may indicate how severe the depressive disorders are that run in the family as well as
predict, to some degree, how likely it is that an individual might commit suicide.
Depression and the Role of Formative Experiences
Psychiatrists often spend a fair amount of time in their initial assessment trying
to understand what the individual's cumulative emotional experience of childhood was
like. The socio-developmental history often provides key information that may pertain
to the development of a depressive disorder. Hence, psychiatrists will often inquire
about:
- The individual's memory of the overall emotional quality of his childhood
(e.g. happy versus unhappy versus mixed)
- The individual's basic temperament, including "affective" or mood temperament (e.g. shy/sensitive/anxious versus
easy-going/relaxed versus difficult) and how these temperamental traits impacted the relationship
between the individual and his family
- Birth order
- The family's emotional well-being at the time of the individual's birth
- The emotional health of the individual's parents' relationship
- Whether either or both parents had significant depression during the
individual's childhood and what that was like for the individual and the
family as a whole
- What the individual's relationship with each parent was like, generally
- What the individual's relationships with siblings were like
- Emotional safety in the home (e.g. Was the home environment warm, loving
and safe? Or unpredictable, tense, and volatile?)
- How the individual was treated at various times of his childhood (e.g.
Was the child loved? Was he shown warmth and affection? Was he respected
and understood? Or, was he resented? Treated with scorn?
Withheld affection? Punished frequently or indiscriminately?)
- History of emotional, physical or sexual abuse
- History of emotional neglect
- Other traumatic experiences in childhood (e.g. death of a parent, illness
/death of a sibling, frequent moves, being bullied, etc.)
- School functioning and how the individual regarded school (enjoyed and
performed well versus disliked and struggled with)
- Presence of a specific learning disorder and/or Attention-Deficit/
Hyperactivity Disorder
- The transition to adolescence and what that was like for the individual,
emotionally speaking
- Risk-taking behavior in adolescence
- Substance abuse in adolescence
I believe that it is critically important for psychiatrists to understand what the predominant mood states were for the individual when he was a child. Were the mood states predominantly negative (sad, depressed, angry, scared) or predominantly positive (content, happy), for example? It seems reasonable to speculate that the ratio of negative mood states to positive mood states in childhood has something to do with the modulation of expression of depressive disorders later in life and that certain experiences that harken back to childhood may serve as psychological triggers for depression later in life.
Suicide Risk Assessment in Depression
In their assessment of a depressive disorder, psychiatrists are taught to invariably conduct a suicide risk assessment. It's always critically important to gauge an individual's current risk for suicide, as depression is thought to be one of the most important risk factor for suicide. If an individual expresses suicidal thoughts or feelings upon being queried, or spontaneously, a psychiatrist will inquire about:
- How often he has those feelings or thoughts
- How intense the thoughts/feelings are
- How long they last when they come on (are they fleeting, do they last
for a few hours or are they unremitting?)
- Whether it ever gets to a point where the individual is ready to take
action or feels an urge to end his life
- Whether he has a plan in mind and what that plan is
- Whether he has access to lethal means (such as a firearm, noose, or
large quantity of medications)
- Whether he is currently using or abusing alcohol and/or other substances
- Whether there is significant agitation (an uncomfortable sense of energy) or anxiety (e.g. panic attacks) that co-occurs with the mood state
- Whether, when the individual is not in an episode of serious depression, he has chronic
thoughts of suicide
- Whether he has made any previous attempts and what the nature of those
attempts were
- If he has written a note
- If he has started to say goodbye to friends and family
- If he feels a sense of relief or calm, having decided to soon kill himself
- If he has people/pets in his life he is responsible for
- Whether there are psychotic symptoms that make suicidal thoughts or impulses
more intense (e.g. a voice telling the person to kill himself, extreme paranoia,
or delusional guilt)
Psychiatrists will also often inquire about previous suicide attempts the individual
may have made, because that information may have some value in predicting the likelihood
that the individual will make another suicide attempt. This information can also reveal
just how severe the individual's prior episodes of depression were, if, in fact, the
suicide attempts were made in the context of depression. (Some individuals who are
highly impulsive and have trouble with affect regulation do not necessarily need to
experience a serious episode of depression in order to make a lethal suicide attempt. At the same time, anxiety states such as severe panic attacks can also increase the likelihood of a suicide attempt.)
Response to Previous Anti-Depressant Medication Trials
Another important area to cover in the psychiatric assessment of a depressive disorder
is whether the individual has been on anti-depressant and/or other psychotropic medications
before. I ask individuals to list all the medications they have taken for regulation of
mood and anxiety. I then list for them the most common medications used to treat mood and
anxiety disorders and ask them if they have ever been on those medications. Then, I try
to construct a chronological list of all medications they have used for regulation of mood
and anxiety and ask them to describe their response to each medication, how long they were
on it, what side-effects they experienced, and why they were either taken off the medication
or discontinued it. Sometimes, individuals have been tried on medication combinations and
if this is the case, I ask how the combinations were arrived at (e.g. only partial efficacy
of the first medication at maximal dose, leading to the addition of a second medication or
use of a second medication to lessen the side-effects of the first, etc.) Sometimes, it
becomes clear that a particular medication stood out as particularly intolerable or that another
one worked best for someone. This information is useful because it will have some bearing on
medication recommendations for the current episode of depression.
|